Here’s the thing, she was never on a date before.
Not for lack of invitations, but for lack of will, of course.
Lily Evans liked her freedom. She liked spending hours in Scrivenshaft without worrying if she’s making someone bored.
She liked hanging with Marlene in Broomsticks laughing gaily, their hairs messy and her comfy warm jeans and her comfy sneakers giving her that weekend breather.
She certainly did not want to wear a skirt in winter like Dorcas had to because the date was in Puddifoot’s and anything longer than a skirt past your knee is frowned upon even in winter.
Yes, Lily Evans would rather like buying her chocolate frogs and her books in her sneakers rather than pay five galleons for a cup of tea.
That is until James Potter of course.
Now see, James Potter also loved his independence. He loved spending hours in Zonko’s without being badgered to go to Puddifoot’s.
He loved to hang out with the Marauders in Broomsticks and laughing without minding his manners.
He loved to wear his reindeer sweaters and he has long given up on his mop of hair.
He liked to simply get his Bertie Bott’s and his prank supplies and throw snow at Sirius with Pete and Remus.
That is until Lily Evans.
Now, the whole of Hogwarts has been waiting for James and Lily to get on with that Hogsmeade date that has been three years overdue, but when James Potter finally asked out Lily Evans near the end of fifth year by that tree with Severus Snape hanging upside down, they gave up all hope of ever seeing James and Lily on a date.
That is until sixth year, when Lily Evans stood up on the bench whilst eating breakfast with her friends and screamed “James you bloody idiot IT WAS ME ASKING YOU OUT ON A DATE!”
See, here was the problem.
When Lily Evans sat down on her sixth year potions class, she expected to be alone because her partner called her a racist slur.
But there was James Potter sitting there sulking, broody (and five times more attractive than when she almost said yes to his invitation to Hogsmeade about three months ago) looking at an equally sullen Sirius. She was prepared to scream at his impertinence.
“Potter what are you-”
“Not today Evans, please.” He finally looked at her and his eyes were red-rimmed and there were shadows under his eyes, and his utter defeat tugged at her heartstrings.
“Not today.”
So she sat down beside him, took out her parchment, her quill and her ink bottle and simply said “Okay.”
He gave her a faint smile and went back to looking at Sirius whilst her heart ran a marathon inside her chest.
She would later find out from Marlene that Sirius Black ran away from home and James Potter had to take him to Mungo’s for his various injuries and has been protecting him ever since. This would cement one thought in Lily’s mind that to be honest she always knew but refused to acknowledge: James Potter is kind.
So the year would go on, and Lily and James would develop a normal acquaintance type of friendship that would eventually evolve to continually eating breakfast together, going to classes engaged in debates about who is better, The Doctor or Newt Scamander and falling asleep on the common room couch, legs tangled together as their various homework parchments flutter around them.
Eventually, the now sometimes broody, less obnoxious but still nerdy cannot talk to girls goof Quidditch captain would start to attract attention from the female populace which he seemed, to Lily’s relief, very ignorant about.
Of course, the rest of the Marauders were always ignorant about the female attention they get, choosing instead to prank each other, and act like a pack of puppies in a romp.
So Lily was doing just fine being James Potter’s friend when Olive Wood started to hang around James after Quidditch practice.
Olive was a fifth year, and she was the younger sister of Keeper, Thomas Wood. Olive recently got the Seeker position and was claiming that she needed to practice with the captain to get in shape for their first match against Slytherin.
James was happy to oblige Olive, and started spending the precious afternoons that were for him and Lily with her.
She started to grate Lily’s nerves a bit, so Lily decided to take matters into her own hands and wrote him a letter asking him out to Hogsmeade.
The doofus, however, misinterpreted the signature - your most ardent friend, for Olive and was a bit befuddled about it at breakfast the next morning.
“So see, Ollie’s a great girl and all, but she’s Thom’s sister and I really don’t think Thom will forgive me for dating his sister.”
Lily gripped her fork in her hand as James prattled on about Ollie and how perfect she was.
“Prongs, look here, if you like Ollie, and you’re a decent bloke who would not break her heart, then what are you afraid of? I mean, you do like Ollie, don’t you?”
Remus prodded him and James seemed to mull it over. Lily stabbed her potato with a knife.
Sirius sent her a sly glance before turning to James once more.
“Answer the question Prongs. You do like Ollie right?”
“I-”
And Lily could not take it anymore and hence stood up on the bench and asked James Potter out in front of the whole of Hogwarts.
Which led to this moment, here in front of the gates an hour before everyone was due to leave for Hogsmeade where James Potter was looking at a dressed up Lily Evans wearing a pink skirt that flowed past her ankles and a white sweater that made her hair seem to catch fire.
She was blushing, because he too was in slate gray pants and James Potter never wore anything but ripped jeans and he tamed his hair and wore leather shoes.
When they both got over the shock, they were presented with the worst conundrum of all - they were going on their first date, with a person they like at the place they hated the most.
It took three seconds of squirming before they both blurted out
“I DON’T WANT TO GO TO PUDDIFOOT’S!”
Which led to widened eyes, and chuckles and utter relief that see, it wasn’t so hard to go on a date, not when you’re just hanging out with your mate.
So he chucked his leather shoes, and mussed up his hair. And she revealed that under the skirt she was wearing her warm comfy jeans, and they raced towards the kitchens munching on Treacle tart and left over Chocolate Frogs and Bertie Botts just having the talk, you know, the kind that never ends.
And the whole of Hogwarts thought that the date did not happen, and money sadly exchanged hands, until Kingsley Shacklebolt would whoop and holler and demand his money from Earl McMillan because there under the beech tree by the lake, James Potter and Lily Evans lay side by side, holding hands and sleeping soundly.
The next Hogsmeade weekend, Lily Evans would be in her ratty jeans, and rattier shoes and her hair would be bunned up messily but her hand was caught in James Potter, who wore his reindeer sweater and his mop of hair going this way and that.
They would spend hours in Scrivenshaft, arguing over self inking quills and in Zonko’s where Lily’s eyes gleamed with each new item James bought (and McGonagall shuddered because she was sure a new Marauder was born). They would eat their fill in Honeydukes and hang out with their friends in Broomsticks. But their hands remained clasped, and their legs would get tangled up, but it was just like every other Hogsmeade weekend they spent alone, but this time, it was just made happier.